SRDS-16 REVIEW FORM

            PLEASE RETURN AS SOON AS POSSIBLE OR AT THE LATEST BY:
                              
                                   MAY 23

To:	Amir A. Abouelnaga  
Email:	amir.a.abouelnaga@trw.com 

Electronic copies of this review form can be obtained from
	http://www.ee.duke.edu/~srds97

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
               INFORMATION FOR THE PROGRAM COMMITTEE ONLY
                     (THIS PAGE IS CONFIDENTIAL)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------

                        REFEREE/PAPER INFORMATION

Referee name (Last, First):______________________________________________

Referee E-mail:__________________________________________________________

Referee Phone, Fax:______________________________________________________

Paper number:____________________________________________________________
   
Title:___________________________________________________________________
   
Author(s):_______________________________________________________________

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

                                 RATING

Please rate the following by entering a number between 0 and 5; 
5 is the highest/best; 0 is the lowest/worst.

	Relevance of SUBJECT (not the paper) to SRDS-16:___

	Confidence in your REVIEW:___
       
	Contribution (i.e, originality) of the PAPER:___

	Correctness of technical content:___

	Presentation style and quality:___

----------------------------------------------------------------------------

                         OVERALL RECOMMENDATION

(5 = Strong accept, 4 = Weak accept, 3 = Marginal, 2 = Weak reject, 
1 = Strong reject)

Please enter a number between 1 and 5 (meanings shown above) HERE:___

In case of acceptance, what is the revision extent (0=minimal, 5=extensive), enter HERE:___

(Note: Please provide comments to authors in the appropriate section below 
so that the paper can be properly revised)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Do you recommend this paper for: 

1) IEEE Transactions on Reliability (Y or N):___

2) IEEE Transactions on Knowledge and Data Engineering (Y or N):___

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

                  CONFIDENTIAL COMMENTS TO PROGRAM COMMITTEE

Enter confidential comments below.  Please do not use this space unless it is 
absolutley necessary.  It is preferable to give informative comments to the author.

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

                        INFORMATION FOR THE AUTHOR(S)

----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Referee Number:____  (Your number should be in the cover letter of your package)

Paper number:_____

Title:___________________________________________________________________

Authors:_________________________________________________________________

-------------------------------------------------------------------------

                        SUMMARY COMMENTS FOR AUTHOR(S)

Please enter the appropriate word from the choices in parentheses.

	Interest of the subject to the SRDS (High/Medium/Low):___

	Originality of the paper (High/Medium/Low):___

	Subject matter (Theory/Paper-Study/Experiment/Practice):___

	Technically sound (Yes/No/Appears to be):___

	Mathematics are essential, complete, correct (Yes/No/Appears to be):___

	Self-contained (Yes/No):___

	Meets submission requirements (length) (Yes/No):___

	Adequate reference to prior works (Yes/No):___

	English is satisfactory (Yes/No):___

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
                         WRITTEN COMMENTS FOR AUTHOR(S)

Please enter your comments for the author(s) on your reasons for accepting
or rejecting the paper.  Reviews lacking informative comments will be
disregarded.